Watchdog Group Tells PM Trudeau to Take Back Canada’s Trash Now While Legal Loopholes Are Being Fixed

EcoWaste Coalition, a watchdog group for chemical safety and zero waste, urged
Prime Minister Justin Trudeau to order the immediate return to Canada of their botched
illegal trash shipments while his government devise a “Canadian solution” to solve
the festering dumping scandal.     
The group insisted that the illegal garbage imports have nowhere to go but
Canada and that the development of a “Canadian solution” should not be used as
an excuse to justify the extended stay of the trash consignments in the country
for temporary storage or permanent disposal. 
At a press conference held yesterday, Trudeau stated that a “Canadian solution”
is being crafted to plug the loopholes that allowed the export of Canadian
trash to the Philippines, but made no commitment on taking back their garbage
as firmly demanded by concerned groups, legislators and citizens.
“I have obviously been made aware of the situation and I’ve also been told that
there is a Canadian solution in the process of being developed. But, at the
same time, I know that this has exposed a problem that needs fixing within our
own legislation that we’re going to lean into and make sure happens,” Trudeau
In reaction, Rene Pineda, Vice-President of the EcoWaste Coalition, said: “Prime
Minister Trudeau must have been made aware that the Basel Convention has become
part of the laws of countries that acceded to it through their
ratification.  And that their enabling
law cannot be inferior than the Convention.”
Pineda was referring to a legally-binding treaty called the “Basel Convention
on the Control of Transboundary Movements of Hazardous Wastes and their
Disposal,” which includes Canada and the Philippines as state parties, that
aims to protect human health and the environment against the adverse effects of
hazardous wastes and other wastes.
“And when he admits the loopholes in Canada’s enabling law, then that’s an
indictment of their violation of the Basel Convention.  As no amount of amendment to Canada’s law
would extricate them from culpability and international shame, Trudeau should
have seized the golden opportunity to display real statemanhood required of
every leader and commit to re-importing Canada’s garbage.  What a waste, what a shame!” he said.
To effectively plug the loopholes that have caused trade in hazardous wastes to
flourish, Pineda challenged the governments of both Canada and the Philippines
to ratify the “Basel Ban Amendment.”
The “Basel Ban Amendment,” introduced in 1995, prohibits highly industrialized
countries from exporting hazardous wastes to developing countries “for final
disposal, reuse, recycling and recovery.” This amendment to the Basel
Convention has yet to enter into force.
The EcoWaste Coalition had earlier commented that “unless the Philippine
government ratifies the ‘Basel Ban Amendment’ and reflects its intent in our
national laws, the country will continue to be a recipient of hazardous garbage
from overseas, made possible under the guise of recycling or recovery.“
Senator Miriam Defensor Santiago in September 2014 filed a resolution calling
for “an inquiry, in aid of legislation, on ways to decisively prevent illegal
waste dumping from abroad, including the ratification of the ‘Basel Convention
Ban Amendment’ and other legal measures to protect the country from becoming a
global dump for hazardous wastes.”
From June 2013 to January 2014, a total of 103 container vans of mixed garbage
from Canada, misdeclared as “plastic scraps” for recycling, entered the country
in 10 batches and subsequently intercepted by customs authorities.
After sitting in the ports, 26 containers of these trash consignments were
illegally disposed of at the Metro Clark Landfill in Tarlac between June 26 to
July 8, 2015, drawing the ire of local officials and residents.