New Study Finds Lead Levels in a Majority of Paints Exceed Chinese Regulation and Should Not be on Store Shelves

Insight Explorer – IPEN Joint Press Release
27 January 2016, Beijing, China. A new study on lead in decorative paints
sold in China released today by Insight Explorer and IPEN finds that more than
half of the paints analyzed exceed Chinese lead regulations. Moreover, even
when paint brands offer paint with lower levels of lead, consumers have no way
of knowing it because very few of 141 paint cans analyzed in the study carried
information about lead content on the label.
“The health impacts of lead exposure on young children’s
brains are lifelong, irreversible and untreatable,” said Pan Qingan, Project
Director of China Heavy Metal Pollution Map. “We are limiting our children and
our nation’s future intellectual development even though safe and effective
alternatives are already in use and widely available in China. We must reduce
this critical source of lead exposure to young children.”
“Chinese children’s blood levels showed significant
decrease after leaded gasoline was banned. Therefore, the continued use of lead
paint will become the primary source of childhood lead exposure,” said Zhang
Jingling, Chinese Research Academy of Environmental Sciences. “First, children
will absorb the extra lead through the gastrointestinal tract by chewing on
objects such as toys, household furniture or other articles painted with lead
paint. Second, exposure to dust or soil contaminated with lead-based paint is
exacerbated by children’s normal hand-to-mouth behavior. We must enforce
existing government regulations on the use of lead in paint in order to
minimize childhood lead exposure and safeguard their health.”
Regulation limiting the amount of lead in paint for
interior and decorative use was introduced in China in 2001, complementing the
Toy Safety standard introduced in 1986 for lead in paint on children´s toys.
Both regulations limit the lead content of paint to 90 ppm of soluble lead,
i.e., the amount of lead that can be extracted by a standard acid treatment to
simulate the amount of lead bioavailable for absorption when e.g., a toy
painted with lead paint is put in the mouth. Laws or regulations to control the
lead content of decorative paints—paints used on the interiors and exteriors of
homes, schools, and other child-occupied facilities—are common in most highly
industrialized countries.
In late 2014, Insight Explorer purchased a total of 141
cans of solvent-based, enamel decorative paints representing 47 brands from
stores in eight cities in China (Beijing, Shenyang, Zhengzhou, Nanchang,
Guangzhou, Xiamen, Shanghai and Kunming). Samples from these paints were
analyzed by an accredited laboratory in Italy for total lead content.
Key findings from the report, Lead in Enamel Decorative
Paints in China, include:
•    Approximately
half of the paints analyzed for this study exceed Chinese lead regulations and
should not be on store shelves. Of the 141 paints analyzed, 70 of the paints
(50% of paints) contained a total lead content above 600 ppm. A 600 ppm total
lead content approximately corresponds to 90 ppm soluble lead, the lead limit
for lead in paint in China.
•     More
than one-third (48 paints; 34% of paints) of the paints contained dangerously
high lead levels above 10,000 ppm total lead and would not be allowed for sale
in any country restricting the use of lead in decorative paint.
•       One or
more paints from 42 of the 47 brands (89% of brands) had a total lead content
below 600 ppm (approximately 90 ppm soluble lead), showing that the technology
exists in China to produce paint within the regulatory limit.
•      Approximately
one-third of the paints had lead levels below 90 ppm – the regulatory standard
for total lead content in many countries, indicating that these companies can
produce products that are safer for Chinese consumers and meet quality
standards for export.
•     Yellow
paints had the highest lead levels and red paints had the second highest lead
•     Consumers
rarely know whether or not paint meets Chinese regulation because very few of
paint cans analyzed carried information about lead content on the label.
The World Health Organization (WHO) calls lead paint “a
major flashpoint” for children’s potential lead poisoning and says that “since
the phase-out of leaded petrol, lead paint is one of the largest sources of
exposure to lead in children.” Children are exposed to lead when painted
surfaces deteriorate over time and contaminate household dust and soils.
Children ages 0-6, engaging in normal hand-to-mouth behaviors, are most at risk
of damage to their intelligence and mental development from exposure to lead
dust and soil.
China is the world’s second largest producer and consumer
of coatings and there may be as many as 8,000 paint producers inside China,
according to the coatings industry magazine, Coatings World. In addition, the
Chinese paint market saw a rapid increase in sales and demand during the past decade.
Though the demand for paint for newly constructed buildings has recently
started to decrease with the slowing of the real estate market, demand for
paint to repaint existing buildings and homes is increasing.
Two previous paint studies were conducted in China in
2009 with a total of 122 paints analyzed. Although the earlier studies included
fewer brands, the percentage of samples with total lead concentrations greater
than 600 ppm and 10,000 ppm are similar among the three studies. Most of these
samples were from brands not included in the current study.
Key recommendations made in the report include:
•     Government:
Establish effective procedures for monitoring and enforcing full compliance
with existing regulatory controls on the lead content of paints manufactured
and sold in China; move toward a total lead regulatory standard to ease burdens
on companies and facilitate regulation.
•   Industry:
Discontinue using lead-based pigments and lead-based drying catalysts as paint
ingredients and provide information on product labels indicating the lead
content of paint.
•    Consumers:
Ask about the lead content of paints and only purchase paints meeting national
The paint study was undertaken as part of the Asian Lead
Paint Elimination Project (2012 – 2015), funded by the European Union with 1.4
million euros. It was implemented by IPEN, a network of 700 NGOs in more than
100 countries working for a toxics-free future.
Insight Explorer (IE) is an environmental NGO established
in 2012 in Beijing. It seeks to increase public awareness and citizens’
capacity to take action in the areas of pollution control, ecosystem and
biodiversity conservation, and sound environmental governance. In September
2013, it launched a project called China Heavy Metal Pollution Map, which
focuses on both pollution hotspots and problematic consumer products caused by
heavy metals.
IPEN is an international NGO network comprised of 700
organizations in 116 countries that work to reduce and eliminate hazardous,
toxic substances internationally and within their own countries. (www.ipen.org)
For More information
Mr. Pan Qingan
Insight Explorer
Address: Rm 1501, Building 3, No. 3, Fengguan Road,
Fengtai District, Beijing, China
Phone: +86 185 1386 7782
Email: panqingan@qq.com
Website: http://zhongjinshu.epmap.org/ngo
Mr. Manny Calonzo
Phone: +639178364691
Email: manny@ipen.org

Website: www.ipen.org